The enquiry arrived as three 3D models and one line of material description: alloy steel. Everything a price normally rests on — general tolerances, thread class, surface finish, the grade itself — was missing. This case is about pricing anyway, without pretending the missing information is not missing.

At a Glance
| Industry | Motorcycle and motorsport suspension dampers (UK) |
|---|---|
| Parts | Three threaded turned parts — M22 and M24 external threads, one part family |
| Material | Alloy steel; no grade given on the enquiry, so quoted as 42CrMo4 (AISI 4140 / 1.7225) and stated as an assumption |
| What we received | STEP 3D models only — no 2D drawing, no general tolerance block, no finish callouts |
| Part size | Ø27.5 × 39.0 mm envelope, 131 g finished — measured from the model geometry |
| Quantity | 12 pcs — three part numbers × 4 pcs, a trial lot for a new product line |
| What we returned | One provisional unit price for the three parts, with material grade, tolerance system and exclusions written on the quotation; firm price within 48 hours of the 2D drawings |
| Trade term | EXW Dongguan — other terms quoted on request |
The Customer
A small British engineering company that services and builds dampers for motorcycles and motorsport. The owner-engineer does the design, the sourcing and the correspondence himself, works from 3D CAD, and had twelve pieces to order to prove a new damper design before it goes to series volume.
The Challenge
- No 2D drawing existed. General tolerances, thread class, surface finish and material grade were all unstated — every one of them normally decides what a part costs.
- Waiting for the drawing is not a neutral choice: it leaves a customer with a new product line and no budget figure. Quoting silently from assumptions is worse, because the price moves later with nothing written down.
- Twelve pieces across three part numbers is a trial lot. Programming and setup are carried by four pieces per part number, and that is where small-lot quotes usually stop being real prices.
- Threads are easy to lose in a 3D workflow. Many models carry simplified cylinders where the thread should be, and a price built on those models quietly leaves the threading operation unpaid.
Our Approach
- The geometry was measured, not assumed. The models were read locally: Ø27.5 × 39.0 mm envelope, 131 g finished part — and the external M22 and M24 threads are present as real modelled surfaces, not simplified diameters. Threading is therefore a priced operation, not an oversight.
- Time priced from the blank, not from the finished part. Bar runs at Ø30 mm with roughly 47 mm consumed per piece once parting and gripping allowance are counted, so material cost and cycle time follow what the machine actually removes.
- The assumptions went on the quotation. Material quoted as 42CrMo4 (AISI 4140) because the enquiry said only "alloy steel"; general tolerances to ISO 2768-m; heat treatment, surface treatment and material certificates excluded and quoted separately if required.
- One price for the family, declared as provisional. Three part numbers came back at a single unit price so a change in mix inside the trial lot does not reopen the commercial conversation — and the quotation states plainly that it is built on the STEP geometry.
- Everything that would move the number, listed in advance: a hardening step, tolerances tighter than ISO 2768-m, a specified certified grade, a finish specification. Each one is a conversation with a number attached rather than a surprise after the order.

Where the Model Met the Machine
| What the enquiry gave us | What we did with it |
|---|---|
| STEP models only, no 2D drawing | Measured the geometry directly — Ø27.5 × 39.0 mm envelope, 131 g finished — and priced from that instead of from a drawing nobody had yet |
| "Alloy steel", no grade | Quoted as 42CrMo4 / AISI 4140 (1.7225) and named the assumption in writing; a certified grade or a hardening step is its own line |
| Thread geometry fully modelled | Treated the M22 / M24 threads as a machining operation — the model carries the real thread form, so the operation is paid for |
| No tolerance block on the enquiry | Quoted to ISO 2768-m general tolerances and asked the customer to say if the 2D drawing will be tighter |
| 12 pcs across three part numbers | One unit price for the family, with programming and setup spread across the trial lot and shown as such inside the price |
A price built from a model is not a weaker price than one built from a drawing — provided the customer can see what is holding it up. That is what the quotation does: material grade, tolerance system and exclusions sit next to the number, so when the drawings land, either the number stands or it changes for a reason we can point at.
What the Customer Received
| Provisional quotation | Built from the 3D geometry alone, so a new product line can be budgeted before the 2D drawings exist |
|---|---|
| Assumptions in writing | Material grade, tolerance system, and what the price excludes — heat treatment, surface treatment, material certificates |
| Threading included | The threads are modelled in full, so the operation is inside the price instead of appearing later as an extra |
| One price for three part numbers | The trial lot can be re-mixed without reopening the price |
| Firm price route | Within 48 hours of the 2D drawings, priced against the revision supplied |
| No minimum order quantity | 12 pieces was a real order size; quantity changes the unit price, not whether we take the work |
Status
The customer replied asking for the price rather than for the drawing, and the quotation went out the same day: three parts, twelve pieces, one unit price, provisional on the three models and valid for 30 days. Nothing further has been requested since.
The next move is the customer's. Send the 2D drawings and the provisional number becomes firm within 48 hours, priced against the revision supplied — or leave the drawings out and the parts are machined from the models as they stand, with the material grade and the ISO 2768-m tolerance system already agreed in writing.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can you quote a part from a 3D model when no 2D drawing exists?
Yes, when the model is a valid solid with real geometry. The part is measured and priced from it, and every assumption holding the number up — material grade, tolerance system, what is excluded — is written on the quotation. The price is declared provisional. What we will not do is present a guess as a firm price.
Do you need a material grade before you can price a part?
"Alloy steel" can mean 4140 / 42CrMo4, a hardening grade such as 42CrMo4 in the quenched and tempered condition, or a free-cutting grade — and the difference mostly shows up in tool wear and cycle time rather than in the bar price. Without a grade we quote a standard assumption and name it in writing.
Is twelve pieces too small an order for a Chinese machine shop?
No. Three part numbers at four pieces each is a normal trial lot for us. Programming and setup are inside the price you see, spread across the lot — quantity changes the unit price, it does not decide whether we take the work. There is no minimum order quantity.
Which threads can you produce?
Metric and inch, internal and external, single-pointed on the lathe or thread-milled. M22 and M24 external threads are routine work. Thread class and fit are checked with gauges, and the inspection record goes out with the parts when the order calls for it.
What happens if the 2D drawings never arrive?
Then we machine from the 3D models with the tolerance system agreed in writing — ISO 2768-m unless something else is confirmed. If a feature later turns out to need a tighter tolerance than that, it is a re-quote against the drawing rather than an argument about what was implied.